Splurge v. Save - Pointy Toe Bow Flats

I've been lusting after the J. Crew Viv Flats, but not the $228 price tag.

I've always had a penchant for pointy toe flats. Add a bow, and you had me at hello. Enter the Me Too Patty Flat at the pocketbook-friendly price of $88.95. And it's a match made in heaven! Now the question is nude or black?